Succession in Brazil: the real cost of not planning

Those who build wealth over decades rarely calculate how much of it actually reaches their heirs. The answer is uncomfortable: between taxes, legal fees, court costs, and the time assets remain frozen, unplanned transfers consume a significant portion of what was accumulated.

It’s not a tax. It’s the price of not having decided beforehand.

How much does probate cost

The cost consists of four main blocks: ITCMD (inheritance tax), legal fees, notary or court costs, and expenses for certificates and regularization. The total depends on the state, the composition of the assets, and whether there is a dispute.

Consider an estate of R$ 5 million. With a 4% ITCMD and 6% in legal fees, the bill already hits R$ 500,000, before any other expenses. Ten percent of the estate just to complete the transfer.

And there is the cost that doesn't appear on the bill: time. An extrajudicial probate, when applicable, is resolved in thirty to ninety days. A judicial one, which becomes mandatory if there is litigation, takes from one to five years. During this period, assets are frozen for transfer, and the income they generate is not automatically available to the heirs.

ITCMD: what it is, how much it costs, and how to reduce it

It is the state tax on transfers due to death or donation. The rate varies by state and can reach 8%, the ceiling set by the Senate, and each state has its own legislation: São Paulo charges 4%, Minas Gerais 5%, and Rio de Janeiro adopts progressive brackets that reach up to 8%.

Two points deserve attention:

The Constitutional Amendment 132 of 2023, made progressivity mandatory in all states. Previously, it was optional. In practice, larger estates will now pay higher rates across the entire federation, and states that charged a flat rate are transitioning.

And the deadline. The Code of Civil Procedure establishes a two-month window after death to open probate. Penalties follow the legislation of each state. In São Paulo, exceeding sixty days without filing for probate triggers a 10% fine on the ITCMD, a percentage that rises to 20% after one hundred and eighty days.

ITCMD (inheritance tax) and probate expenses require liquid cash, often before the family can access the estate's assets. This is why even wealthy families often sell assets well below market value shortly after a death: they have net worth, but no cash.

The three legitimate ways to reduce costs are to transfer assets while state tax rates are still lower, choose instruments that are not subject to probate, and structure asset ownership before the event occurs. None of these work after the fact.

What is excluded from probate

Here is the most underutilized tool in Brazilian estate planning.

Private pension plans and life insurance policies have designated beneficiaries. Funds are paid directly to them, bypassing probate and the lengthy distribution process.

And there is a significant update: the Supreme Federal Court, in Ruling 1214, established that it is unconstitutional to levy ITCMD on PGBL and VGBL pension funds transferred to beneficiaries upon the policyholder's death. It is no longer a matter of which state offers an exemption; it is a nationwide prohibition.

The practical effect is twofold. Beyond the tax savings, these funds reach the family in days, not years, and serve specifically to pay the ITCMD on other assets without anyone needing to liquidate property in a rush.

A pension plan sized to cover the estimated tax on other assets is one of the most efficient decisions available, yet one of the least utilized.

Wills or lifetime gifts

They solve different problems and are not mutually exclusive.

A will governs the disposable portion of an estate, which is up to 50% when there are forced heirs. The other 50% is the mandatory share and cannot be diverted. A will does not avoid probate or reduce taxes, but it drastically reduces the risk of litigation, which is the primary driver of costs and delays.

A lifetime gift transfers the asset immediately, with ITCMD due at the time of the gift. It is usually executed with a reserved usufruct, allowing the donor to retain possession and income for life. The advantage is locking in current tax rates before any potential increases.

The common mistake is choosing between the two. An efficient plan usually employs both, combined with instruments that remain outside of probate.

Is a family holding company worth it?

It depends, and the honest answer is that they are sold more often than they are justified.

It makes sense when there is significant real estate, corporate holdings, more than one heir, and a concrete risk of conflict. In these cases, a holding company organizes governance, facilitates the distribution of shares rather than physical assets, and can create tax efficiency on rental income.

Supplementary Law 227 of 2026 introduced another point of concern: the valuation of shares for calculating ITCMD (inheritance tax) must consider the market value of the company's assets and liabilities, in accordance with state legislation. This can increase the tax burden even without a change in the tax rate. Placing real estate into a holding company, therefore, does not guarantee a cheaper transfer.

It does not make sense when the estate is primarily composed of liquid assets, or when the cost of maintaining the structure, including accounting and ancillary obligations, exceeds the projected savings.

A holding company is a tool, not a solution. A structure set up without a prior diagnosis usually costs more than the probate process it was intended to avoid.

Where the consultant fits in and where the lawyer fits in

The legal execution belongs to the lawyer: deeds, articles of association, wills, and clauses.

What precedes this is diagnosis. Mapping what exists, estimating the tax due in each scenario, verifying if there is liquidity to cover it, identifying which assets would stall the distribution, and sizing up the instruments that remain outside of probate. Without this step, the legal team executes a structure based on premises that no one has verified.

And regarding operations, two frequent questions.

The consultant does not require a change of custody. Your investments remain at the institution where they already are, and the recommendation is made based on what exists there, not on anyone's pre-selected list.

And tax guidance is part of the work: redemption order, taxation of gains, and choosing vehicles with different tax regimes. Paying less tax within the law is a return that does not depend on timing the market.

What remains

Unplanned succession is not neutral. It has a price, and that price is paid at the worst possible moment, by those who are grieving and uninformed.

Every instrument capable of reducing this cost depends on one thing only: existing beforehand. After the event, you are left with the full tax, the full timeline, and decisions made in a rush.

Succession planning is not about dying. It is about deciding while you are still able to decide.

If you want to size up the real cost of your succession before committing to any legal structure, learn about our Family Estate Planning.

‍